Delicious Ice Cream Flavors for Everyone

With 40 different ice cream flavors at Big Olaf Ice Cream & Coffee Caffe in Venice, Florida, we're confident that we have something you'll absolutely adore. While other shops can only offer a few flavors, we're the only one in the area to provide such a large variety. All our selection is handmade by the Amish community in Sarasota. The taste is truly incredible. Our menu features just some of our special concoctions.

Black Cherry	Pink cherry ice cream with black cherries
Black Raspberry	Vanilla based ice cream with black raspberry puree and juices
Blueberry Cheesecake	Cheesecake ice cream loaded with cheesecake pieces and blueberry swirl
Brownie Fudge	Milk chocolate ice cream with chewy brownie pieces
Chocolate Peanut Butter	Chocolate peanut butter ice cream with mini peanut butter cups and peanut butter swirl
Coconut Almond Joy^®	Coconut ice cream with almonds and chocolate flakes
Cookie Dough	Brown sugar molasses base bursting with cookie dough and chocolate flakes
Double Dutch Caramel	(Dulce De Leche) Caramel ice cream with a caramel swirl
Espresso Chip	Espresso flavored ice cream with chocolate flakes
Heath Bar^®	Toffee flavored ice cream with chunks of Heath Bar candy
Kahula Krunch	Kahlua^® liqueur ice cream with mocha chip and chocolate flakes
Mocha Almond Fudge	Mocha ice cream with roasted, salted, almonds, and fudge ripple
Orange Pineapple	Tropical tasting orange and pineapple
Peppermint	Peppermint flavored ice cream
Plantation Praline	Vanilla ice cream with praline pecans and a caramel swirl
Rocky Road	Chocolate ice cream with double dipped chocolate almonds and marshmallow swirl
Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel	Caramel flavored ice cream with pretzel piece and a hint of salt added
Superman	Vanilla flavored ice cream with red, white, and blue Superman™ colors
Trash Can	Vanilla ice cream with Oreos^®, M&M'S^®, peanut butter cups, Heath Bar, Snickers^®, and chocolate flakes
Vanilla Brownie Caramel	Vanilla ice cream with brownie pieces and caramel
White Chocolate Raspberry	White chocolate flavored ice cream infused with raspberry puree and loaded with raspberry cups and white chocolate chips